Akataleptos Forensics "Eyes clenched tight, Truth sprawled out before him, He trips! — STUPID PLACE TO SIT!"
Case Ref: OFH-2025-001-FP
Comprehensive Forensic Analysis

# The Full Picture — A Deductive Theory of the Old Fire House Conspiracy

Complete synthesis of six months of forensic analysis
Date
February 2026
Case Reference
OFH-2025-001-FP
Prepared By
Akataleptos Forensics
Contact
forensics@akataleptos.com

## A Deductive Theory of the Old Fire House Conspiracy

### Redmond, Washington — 2019-2025

This document synthesizes six months of forensic analysis, PRA production review, campaign finance records, patent research, network analysis, and public records into a single coherent theory. Where evidence is direct, it is cited. Where connections are inferred, the inference is marked and the reasoning shown. The standard applied throughout is preponderance — more likely than not.

## THE THESIS

The closure of the Old Fire House teen center was not a facilities decision. It was the final step in a six-year coordinated effort to transfer publicly-owned downtown Redmond real estate to private development interests — an effort that began the week Angela Birney was elected Mayor, was sustained through a manufactured social media infrastructure, executed through selective PRA suppression, and financed by the same developers who stand to profit from the cleared land.

## THE FLOWCHART

                        ┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
                        │     NOVEMBER 5, 2019                │
                        │     Angela Birney Elected Mayor      │
                        │     Funded 4:1 by NLG + developers   │
                        └──────────────┬──────────────────────┘
                                       │
                        ┌──────────────┴──────────────────────┐
                        │     NOVEMBER 11-30, 2019             │
                        │     15 Medium shell accounts created  │
                        │     by Keith Birney's network         │
                        │     6 DAYS after election              │
                        └──────────────┬──────────────────────┘
                                       │
                        ┌──────────────┴──────────────────────┐
                        │     NOVEMBER 19, 2019                │
                        │     Lame-duck council dissolves       │
                        │     Redmond Public Corporation        │
                        │     (Ord. 2979) — assets to City      │
                        │     + zoning changes (Ord. 2978)      │
                        │     14 days after election             │
                        └──────────────┬──────────────────────┘
                                       │
                        ┌──────────────┴──────────────────────┐
                        │     DECEMBER 2019                    │
                        │     Cultural resources ordinance      │
                        │     (Ord. 2982) — OFH deliberately    │
                        │     NOT given landmark protection     │
                        └──────────────┬──────────────────────┘
                                       │
                        ┌──────────────┴──────────────────────┐
                        │     JANUARY 2020                     │
                        │     Birney takes office. Sits on      │
                        │     OneRedmond board with NLG,        │
                        │     developers who funded her.        │
                        └──────────────┬──────────────────────┘
                                       │
                  ┌────────────────────┼────────────────────┐
                  │                    │                     │
                  ▼                    ▼                     ▼
       ┌──────────────────┐ ┌──────────────────┐ ┌──────────────────┐
       │  MARCH 2020      │ │  2020            │ │  2017-2023       │
       │  Emergency decl.  │ │  NLG files       │ │  $94,370 in OFH  │
       │  suspends normal  │ │  LAND-2020-00891 │ │  capital requests │
       │  procurement      │ │  244 units       │ │  DENIED           │
       │  oversight        │ │  ADJACENT to OFH │ │  Revenue starved  │
       └────────┬─────────┘ └────────┬─────────┘ │  to 5.8% of goal  │
                │                    │            └────────┬─────────┘
                ▼                    │                     │
       ┌──────────────────┐          │                     │
       │  COVID COVER-UP  │          │                     │
       │  Whistleblower   │          │                     │
       │  $50K investig.  │          │                     │
       │  (1¢ under       │          │                     │
       │  threshold)      │          │                     │
       │  Chief fired +   │          │                     │
       │  $95K NDA        │          │                     │
       │  PLAYBOOK TEST   │          │                     │
       └────────┬─────────┘          │                     │
                │                    │                     │
                └────────────────────┼─────────────────────┘
                                     │
                        ┌────────────┴─────────────────────────┐
                        │     JANUARY 2023                      │
                        │     "Alternate Facilities Plan"       │
                        │     appears in OFH team agendas       │
                        │     CLOSURE PLANNED 2+ YEARS EARLY    │
                        └────────────┬─────────────────────────┘
                                     │
                        ┌────────────┴─────────────────────────┐
                        │     DEC 2023 - JAN 2024               │
                        │     @json.knight posts 10 fake        │
                        │     articles with hidden backlinks     │
                        │     to 46+ fake persona websites       │
                        │     hosted on Vacares LLC + MojoHost   │
                        └────────────┬─────────────────────────┘
                                     │
                        ┌────────────┴─────────────────────────┐
                        │     EARLY 2024                        │
                        │     Kenmore REJECTS Plymouth Housing   │
                        └────────────┬─────────────────────────┘
                                     │
                        ┌────────────┴─────────────────────────┐
                        │     APRIL 2-16, 2024                  │
                        │     22-DAY SPRINT                     │
                        │     Sato proposes Transfer Option →    │
                        │     Kenny negotiates → Helland         │
                        │     presents to Council → Birney       │
                        │     signs SAME DAY                     │
                        │     $5.5M public land given free       │
                        │     ZERO public hearings               │
                        └────────────┬─────────────────────────┘
                                     │
                        ┌────────────┴─────────────────────────┐
                        │     JULY 31, 2024                     │
                        │     Internal: OFH becomes             │
                        │     "satellite site" — decision made   │
                        │     8 MONTHS before public told        │
                        └────────────┬─────────────────────────┘
                                     │
                        ┌────────────┴─────────────────────────┐
                        │     SEP 2024 — JAN 2025               │
                        │     ██████ FIVE-MONTH BLACK HOLE █████ │
                        │     Zero emails in PRA production     │
                        │     Transfer finalized, PR firm hired, │
                        │     closure machinery assembled        │
                        │     IN TOTAL DARKNESS                  │
                        └────────────┬─────────────────────────┘
                                     │
                        ┌────────────┴─────────────────────────┐
                        │     NOVEMBER 14, 2024                 │
                        │     Stepherson & Associates hired      │
                        │     $4,468.75/month — MORE than        │
                        │     building maintenance ($3,083/mo)   │
                        │     PR costs > actual upkeep           │
                        └────────────┬─────────────────────────┘
                                     │
                        ┌────────────┴─────────────────────────┐
                        │     FEBRUARY-MARCH 2025               │
                        │     THE MACHINE ACTIVATES              │
                        │     - Talking points manufactured      │
                        │     - Mayor personally sanitizes comms │
                        │     - FCA draft watermark removed      │
                        │     - Embargoed press materials        │
                        │     - Template citizen responses       │
                        └────────────┬─────────────────────────┘
                                     │
                        ┌────────────┴─────────────────────────┐
                        │     MARCH 11, 2025                    │
                        │     PUBLIC ANNOUNCEMENT                │
                        │     Community has <3 weeks notice      │
                        │     2,104+ petition signatures         │
                        │     in first weekend                   │
                        └────────────┬─────────────────────────┘
                                     │
                  ┌──────────────────┼──────────────────────┐
                  │                  │                       │
                  ▼                  ▼                       ▼
       ┌──────────────────┐ ┌───────────────────┐ ┌──────────────────┐
       │  SUPPRESSION     │ │  SURVEILLANCE     │ │  PRA RESPONSE   │
       │  Steve Fields    │ │  Sasha Glenn      │ │  Request #32782  │
       │  (opponent)      │ │  tracked, staff   │ │  80% padding     │
       │  114 emails      │ │  report reaches   │ │  911+ withheld   │
       │  WITHHELD        │ │  Mayor in 13.5hrs │ │  4,109 attach.   │
       │                  │ │  Code of Conduct  │ │  stripped         │
       │  Salahuddin      │ │  weaponized:      │ │  96% corruption  │
       │  0 sent produced │ │  warn→suspend→    │ │  Zero Kenmore    │
       │                  │ │  permanent expel  │ │  March 30 cutoff │
       └────────┬─────────┘ └───────┬───────────┘ └────────┬─────────┘
                │                   │                       │
                └───────────────────┼───────────────────────┘
                                    │
                        ┌───────────┴───────────────────────────┐
                        │     MARCH 30, 2025                     │
                        │     PRA PRODUCTION STOPS               │
                        │     Everything after this is invisible  │
                        └───────────┬───────────────────────────┘
                                    │
                        ┌───────────┴───────────────────────────┐
                        │     APRIL 2025                         │
                        │     Council votes 5-1: Omnibus          │
                        │     Financing Resolution                │
                        │     NO PUBLIC COMMENT ALLOWED           │
                        │     (One dissent — identity unknown)    │
                        └───────────┬───────────────────────────┘
                                    │
                        ┌───────────┴───────────────────────────┐
                        │     MAY 10, 2025                       │
                        │     Downtown Redmond light rail opens   │
                        │     Property values SURGE               │
                        │     OFH lot: est. $5M+ and climbing     │
                        └───────────┬───────────────────────────┘
                                    │
                        ┌───────────┴───────────────────────────┐
                        │     JUNE 28, 2025                      │
                        │     New zoning code effective           │
                        │     OFH site: up to 144 ft / FAR 8.0   │
                        │     Potential: 300-400 luxury units     │
                        └───────────┬───────────────────────────┘
                                    │
                        ┌───────────┴───────────────────────────┐
                        │     NOVEMBER 2025                      │
                        │     Steve Fields loses council seat     │
                        │     to Vivek Prakriya                   │
                        │     The opposition voice is removed     │
                        └───────────┬───────────────────────────┘
                                    │
                        ┌───────────┴───────────────────────────┐
                        │     NOVEMBER 18, 2025                  │
                        │     Council votes 6-0 to DEMOLISH      │
                        │     and "rebuild"                       │
                        │     NO BUDGET SET. NO TIMELINE.         │
                        │     Nothing prevents selling the        │
                        │     cleared lot instead.                │
                        └───────────┬───────────────────────────┘
                                    │
                                    ▼
                        ┌───────────────────────────────────────┐
                        │            THE ENDGAME                 │
                        │                                        │
                        │     A cleared, transit-adjacent,       │
                        │     upzoned lot worth $5M+             │
                        │     with no landmark protection        │
                        │     no budget for rebuilding           │
                        │     no timeline for rebuilding         │
                        │     next door to NLG's 22-acre         │
                        │     development empire                 │
                        │     and the developer who funded       │
                        │     the mayor who made it happen       │
                        │                                        │
                        │     "It was decided."                  │
                        │     — City of Redmond, passive voice   │
                        └───────────────────────────────────────┘

## THE CONSPIRACY: LAYER BY LAYER

### Layer 1: The Land Play (PROVEN)

This layer requires zero speculation. Every element is documented.

The facts:
- Nelson Legacy Group owns 22 contiguous acres in downtown Redmond, physically adjacent to the OFH at 16508 NE 79th Street (OFH is at 16510)
- NLG donated $11,000+ to Birney’s campaigns — her single largest donor bloc
- NLG holds THREE seats on the OneRedmond board (no other company holds more than one)
- Mayor Birney sits on the OneRedmond board alongside NLG principals
- NLG filed for 244 units adjacent to OFH in Birney’s first year (LAND-2020-00891)
- The city systematically denied $94,370 in OFH capital requests over six years, starving the facility to a 5.8% revenue capture rate, creating the “Poor” condition that justified closure
- The new zoning code (June 2025) allows 144 feet / FAR 8.0 on the OFH site — 300-400 units
- Council voted 6-0 to demolish with no budget and no timeline for rebuilding

The inference (preponderance): The OFH was deliberately starved, closed, and slated for demolition to clear a transit-adjacent lot for private development by the same interests that funded the mayor and sit on her business coalition board. The “rebuild” vote is a placeholder — with no budget and no timeline, there is nothing preventing a future council from declaring the cleared lot surplus and selling it. NLG, sitting next door with 22 acres already in play, is the obvious buyer.

Confidence: HIGH. The physical adjacency + donor relationship + board overlap + systematic defunding + zoning changes + demolition vote with no rebuild commitment is too convergent to be coincidental.

### Layer 2: The Plymouth Housing Maneuver (PROVEN + INFERRED)

The facts:
- Plymouth Housing was rejected by Kenmore
- Within 22 days, Plymouth pivoted to Redmond
- Andrea Sato proposed a Transfer Option Agreement on April 2, 2024
- Daniel Kenny (city outside counsel) negotiated terms
- Carol Helland presented it to Council on April 16, 2024
- Mayor Birney signed it the same day it was presented
- $5.5M in assessed land value given free. $49.3M total project. Zero RFP. Zero public hearing
- Plymouth Housing is a OneRedmond member organization
- The PRA production contains 142 emails mentioning Plymouth but ZERO emails mentioning Kenmore
- Council voted 5-1 on the Omnibus Financing Resolution with no public comment period

The inference (preponderance): Plymouth Housing was not a charity receiving a gift — it was a mechanism. The city needed a politically defensible reason to dispose of public property without the optics of selling directly to developers. “Supportive housing for the homeless” is unchallengeable in progressive Eastside politics. Anyone who opposes it can be labeled a NIMBY (as Salahuddin literally did in texts).

The 22-day sprint is the tell. Government doesn’t move that fast by accident. The infrastructure was already in place — the legal teams, the board relationships, the political cover. Kenmore’s rejection wasn’t a setback; it was an opportunity. Redmond was ready because the groundwork had already been laid through OneRedmond.

The zero Kenmore emails are the smoking gun. In 7,573 PRA documents about a property deal that originated from a Kenmore rejection, there is not one mention of Kenmore. That’s not an oversight — that’s a purge.

The speculative thread: Plymouth Housing’s $321M in assets and nonprofit status make it an ideal vehicle for moving public property into development-adjacent uses. Once Plymouth builds 120 units of supportive housing on the Cleveland Street parcel, the surrounding property values are theoretically depressed for residential but the “social services hub” designation actually increases the political justification for additional density. The city can then point to “existing social infrastructure” as a reason to upzone further — benefiting NLG and other adjacent landowners.

Confidence: HIGH for the core deal. MODERATE for the value-engineering theory.

### Layer 3: The Medium Shell Network (PROVEN + SPECULATIVE)

The facts:
- Keith Birney (Mayor’s spouse) maintains a Medium account (@keithbirney) with 0 articles, 24 following, 32 followers
- 15 accounts were created November 11-30, 2019 — beginning 6 days after Angela Birney’s election
- All 15 accounts have 0 articles and near-identical following/follower counts (~56/~54)
- The accounts divide into two employer clusters: Microsoft/Bing (Payne, Hullender, Prakash, Raman, Bindal) and Facebook/Meta (Birney, Grover, Markov, Rothbart, Yao)
- The network includes Christopher Payne (former MS CVP, later DoorDash President/COO) and Amit Prakash (founding Bing engineer)
- New zero-article accounts were still being added as recently as October-November 2025
- The @json.knight account posted 10 fake articles containing hidden backlinks to 46+ fake persona websites
- Those websites are hosted on Vacares LLC (purpose-built shell company in Austin, TX) and MojoHost (adult industry hosting)
- All persona sites contain hidden cloaking detection (IP, User Agent, Referrer, Mobile, Search Engine flags)
- On August 6, 2025, 14 of 15 persona domains were updated in a single 25-minute session

Keith Birney’s technical profile:
- Named inventor on US Patent 7,502,773: “System and Method Facilitating Page Indexing Employing Reference Information” (Microsoft, 2009)
- Named inventor on US Patent 7,676,553: “Incremental Web Crawler Using Chunks” (Microsoft, 2010)
- Both patents describe the exact technical skills needed to build a backlink farm: web crawling, page indexing, link graph manipulation

The inference (preponderance): The Medium network is not a social circle that happens to follow Keith Birney. Social circles don’t create 15 accounts in 19 days with identical metrics and zero content. This is infrastructure — built for a purpose, maintained over six years, and connected to a professional-grade SEO/backlink operation.

The speculative threads:

Thread A — Astroturfing Machine: The shell network exists to manufacture the appearance of grassroots support. With 30+ accounts that appear to be real Microsoft/Facebook engineers, the network can flood public comment periods, boost Medium articles supporting city policy, and create the illusion of tech-community consensus. Redmond’s demographics make this especially effective — a comment from “Christopher Payne, Microsoft” carries more weight than an anonymous post. Whether these real people know their identities are being used is an open question.

Thread B — SEO Manipulation for Political Cover: The @json.knight backlink farm and fake persona websites suggest something more sophisticated than astroturfing. Backlink farms exist to manipulate search engine rankings. What would a mayor’s spouse want to push up — or push down — in Google results? Possible targets: negative coverage of city decisions, PRA-related stories, community opposition websites, the OFH petition, Jonathan Choe’s reporting. If you control the first page of Google results for “Redmond Old Fire House” or “Plymouth Housing Redmond,” you control the narrative.

Thread C — Money Laundering Infrastructure: The fake persona websites, registered through privacy shields in Iceland, hosted on infrastructure shared with adult/escort domains, with hidden cloaking systems — this is not amateur hour. This is the same architecture used for SEO fraud, click fraud, and affiliate marketing scams. The Vacares LLC shell company exists solely to host these domains. Someone is paying for this infrastructure. The question is whether the payments flow through Keith Birney’s undisclosed employment (missing from 2024 financial disclosure), through consulting income, or through another channel entirely.

Thread D — The Patent Connection: Keith Birney holds patents on web crawling and page indexing technology. These patents expired December 31, 2023. The @json.knight backlink articles were posted December 3, 2023 through January 4, 2024 — straddling the exact expiration date. This could be coincidence, or it could indicate that the technology described in the patents was being used while still technically under employer assignment, and the operation expanded once the patents expired and the tech was no longer encumbered by Microsoft’s IP claims.

Confidence: HIGH that the network is artificial and maintained. MODERATE for astroturfing. SPECULATIVE for SEO manipulation and money laundering, but the infrastructure is consistent with both.

### Layer 4: The PRA Suppression Machine (PROVEN)

The facts:
- 7,573 documents produced. 79.7% are padding (duplicates, noise, boilerplate)
- 911+ emails proven withheld through reply-to chain analysis
- 4,109 emails (54.3%) had attachments stripped — 35,455 individual attachment references, 288 unique filenames
- 96% file corruption rate (5,967 of 6,213 raw .msg files)
- 10 ghost entities confirmed: people with hundreds of emails TO them but zero outgoing
- Mayor Birney: 8 unique emails in production, 1,838 mentions. 229.8:1 mention-to-sent ratio
- Salahuddin: 298 received, 0 sent, 105 reply-to proofs
- Steve Fields (political opponent): 325 received, 0 sent, 114 reply-to proofs
- Five-month gap: September 2024 through January 2025 — zero emails
- Production stops March 30, 2025 — council votes, Plymouth deal, and demolition all happen after
- Zero Kenmore mentions in entire production
- 45 documented instances of “give me a call” — channel switching to avoid records
- 537 narrative control language hits, 531 pressure/fear language hits
- 11,005 privilege disclaimers but only 2 emails mentioning “records request”

The inference (certain): This is not incompetence. The suppression is surgical:

1. Who is missing? The Mayor, the Deputy Mayor, the political opponent, the City Clerk, the City Council general address. These are the decision-makers.
2. What is missing? Outgoing emails from decision-makers, all attachments (contracts, financials, legal docs), the entire five-month planning period, everything after March 30.
3. What was kept? Duplicates (padding), citizen complaint emails (makes the city look responsive), PR coordination (shows they “communicated”), and enough breadcrumbs to technically comply without revealing substance.

The 96% file corruption is the most damning element. OLE2 container headers are intact but internal MAPI property streams are corrupted. This is consistent with programmatic manipulation — running emails through a tool that strips specific content while preserving the container structure. Multiple copies of the same email have significantly different file sizes (up to 15.9 MB difference), proving progressive content stripping across installments.

The speculative thread: The city likely used an eDiscovery platform (common in municipal records management) that allows selective redaction at the property level. Someone with admin access to that platform — likely in the City Clerk’s office or IT department — configured export rules that stripped attachments, corrupted sender metadata for sensitive emails, and excluded date ranges corresponding to the most sensitive decisions. The City Clerk’s office is itself a ghost entity (27 received, 0 sent, 15 reply-to proofs), which is either a remarkable coincidence or evidence that the office responsible for records compliance was itself excluded from the production.

Confidence: CERTAIN for deliberate suppression. HIGH for programmatic manipulation. MODERATE for the specific eDiscovery theory.

### Layer 5: The Campaign Finance Circuit (PROVEN + INFERRED)

The facts:
- Birney raised $227,013 across three campaigns
- Current surplus: ~$25,631 (potentially higher — committee still active, 4-year PO Box rented through 2027)
- NLG bloc: $11,000+ (largest donor group, physically adjacent to OFH)
- Developer/real estate total: $15,000+
- Out-of-state corporate: Waste Management Houston ($1,450, maxed), AT&T Dallas ($1,000), Comcast Philadelphia ($1,000)
- Waste Management held exclusive no-bid garbage contract since 1994; donated to Birney during contract period
- OneRedmond board members who are also Birney donors: Steve Yoon (Mill Creek, $125), Angela Rozmyn (Natural & Built Environments, $400), Barb Wilson (Microsoft, $125)
- WA surplus fund rules allow indefinite retention for “public office expenses” with minimal oversight
- PDC is complaint-driven, not audit-driven — no proactive investigation
- 2023 race: Birney raised $117,127 against an opponent who raised $6,493 (18:1 ratio) and won 70-30

The inference (preponderance): The 18:1 fundraising ratio against a non-competitive opponent is the key anomaly. You don’t raise $117,000 to beat someone raising $6,500. You raise $117,000 because the donors expect something in return, and the campaign committee is the legal vehicle for receiving it.

The money flows in a circle:
1. Developers donate to Birney
2. Birney makes land-use decisions that benefit those developers
3. Property values increase
4. Developers donate more
5. Repeat

This isn’t unusual in municipal politics. What makes Redmond’s version notable is the concentration: one developer (NLG) holds three board seats on the business coalition, sits physically adjacent to the target property, and represents the single largest donor bloc. The circuit isn’t hidden — it’s just normalized.

The speculative threads:

Thread A — Surplus as Slush Fund: With ~$25,631 sitting in the campaign account and minimal PDC oversight, the surplus functions as a personal discretionary fund. WA law allows spending on “nonreimbursed public office-related expenses” — which can include meals, travel, and office costs. The 2017 Seattle Times investigation found legislators buying suits, D.C. hotel stays, and furniture with surplus funds. No enforcement actions were taken. Birney’s surplus is smaller but the principle is identical.

Thread B — The Keith Birney Income Gap: Keith Birney’s 2020 financial disclosure lists Facebook as his employer ($200,000-$499,999). His 2024 disclosure lists NO employer. His 401k and brokerage accounts show $800,000-$1,450,000 in retirement assets. There is no WA state business registration under his name. Where is the income coming from? Options: (a) he retired, (b) he’s consulting through an LLC registered elsewhere, (c) he’s receiving income through a structure that doesn’t require WA registration. The missing employer, combined with the active Medium shell network and professional-grade backlink infrastructure, suggests income sources that are deliberately obscured.

Thread C — The Waste Management Model: WM held an exclusive no-bid contract since 1994, donated to both the outgoing and incoming mayors, and maxed out to Birney in 2023. This is the template: give a company a monopoly contract, receive campaign donations, repeat for decades. The 2024 switch to Recology (first competitive process in 30 years) either means the model broke down or the players changed. NLG’s development agreements may function the same way — long-term entitlements that survive individual elections, creating a permanent donation incentive.

Confidence: HIGH for the circular donation pattern. MODERATE for surplus misuse. SPECULATIVE for the Keith Birney income gap, but the facts supporting the inference are documented.

### Layer 6: The Suppression Playbook (PROVEN — USED THREE TIMES)

The same operational pattern appears in three separate incidents:

    ┌──────────────────────┬────────────────────────┬───────────────────────┐
    │    COVID COVER-UP    │   PLYMOUTH HOUSING     │   OLD FIRE HOUSE      │
    │    (March 2020)      │   (2024)               │   (2025)              │
    ├──────────────────────┼────────────────────────┼───────────────────────┤
    │                      │                        │                       │
    │ 1. DECIDE IN SECRET  │ 1. DECIDE IN SECRET    │ 1. DECIDE IN SECRET   │
    │ COO: "stay quiet"    │ 22-day sprint, zero    │ Internal since Jan    │
    │                      │ hearings               │ 2023, public told     │
    │                      │                        │ Mar 2025              │
    ├──────────────────────┼────────────────────────┼───────────────────────┤
    │                      │                        │                       │
    │ 2. CONTROL MESSAGE   │ 2. CONTROL MESSAGE     │ 2. CONTROL MESSAGE    │
    │ City-managed         │ Wing PR coordination   │ S&A hired 4 months   │
    │ narrative            │                        │ early, Mayor edits    │
    │                      │                        │ talking points, FCA   │
    │                      │                        │ watermark removed     │
    ├──────────────────────┼────────────────────────┼───────────────────────┤
    │                      │                        │                       │
    │ 3. SILENCE DISSENT   │ 3. SILENCE DISSENT     │ 3. SILENCE DISSENT    │
    │ Fire Chief fired +   │ Opponents = "NIMBYs"   │ Fields emails purged  │
    │ $95K NDA             │ Choe banned from        │ Glenn surveilled +    │
    │                      │ meetings               │ Code of Conduct       │
    │                      │                        │ weaponized            │
    ├──────────────────────┼────────────────────────┼───────────────────────┤
    │                      │                        │                       │
    │ 4. DESTROY EVIDENCE  │ 4. DESTROY EVIDENCE    │ 4. DESTROY EVIDENCE   │
    │ Investigation billed │ Zero Kenmore emails    │ 80% padding, 911+    │
    │ at $49,999.99        │ Zero public record of  │ withheld, 4,109      │
    │ (1¢ under threshold) │ decision-making        │ attachments stripped, │
    │                      │                        │ 96% file corruption   │
    ├──────────────────────┼────────────────────────┼───────────────────────┤
    │                      │                        │                       │
    │ 5. GAME THRESHOLDS   │ 5. GAME THRESHOLDS     │ 5. GAME THRESHOLDS   │
    │ $49,999.99 avoids    │ Same-day signing avoids │ "It was decided"     │
    │ $50K oversight       │ deliberation period    │ passive voice avoids  │
    │                      │                        │ attributable decision │
    └──────────────────────┴────────────────────────┴───────────────────────┘

The inference (certain): This is not three separate incidents. This is one administration running one playbook. The COVID cover-up was the beta test — and it worked. No consequences. The Plymouth Housing deal was the same playbook applied to a property transfer. The OFH closure is the playbook at full maturity, with a professional PR firm, a sophisticated PRA suppression operation, and physical surveillance of a community advocate.

The escalation is notable: from “stay quiet” (verbal, informal) to “give me a call” (documented channel-switching) to a formal five-point surveillance report that reaches the Mayor in 13.5 hours. The administration is getting more organized at suppression, not less.

### Layer 7: The Full Theory (SPECULATIVE — DEDUCTIVE PREPONDERANCE)

Weaving all six layers together:

2019: The Setup

Angela Birney is elected Mayor of Redmond with $105,000 in developer money — 4x her opponent. Within six days, her husband’s network creates 15 Medium shell accounts using the real names and faces of Microsoft and Facebook engineers. Within 14 days, the lame-duck council dissolves the Redmond Public Corporation (freeing assets), passes zoning amendments, and approves a 170-unit development agreement. Within a month, the cultural resources ordinance is written to deliberately exclude the Old Fire House from landmark protection.

Why the shell accounts? Because the incoming administration knows it will need manufactured public support for unpopular decisions. The tech-industry names provide credibility. The zero-article accounts are sleeper cells — activated when needed, invisible when not.

2020: The Test Run

The COVID cover-up serves as a proof of concept. Suppress information (“stay quiet”), control the investigation (sole-sourced at $49,999.99 — one penny under the oversight threshold), silence the whistleblower (fired + $95,778 NDA). It works. No consequences. The administration learns it can suppress, gaslight, and pay off opposition without accountability.

Meanwhile, NLG files for 244 units adjacent to the OFH. The capital request pipeline for OFH is already being strangled — $94,370 denied over six years, including safety and ADA improvements. The building’s condition score is being manufactured.

2021-2023: The Starvation

The OFH is systematically defunded. Revenue targets are set at $106,271 but actual revenue is $6,129 (5.8%). Capital requests are denied. The building deteriorates — not from age, but from neglect. By January 2023, “Alternate Facilities Plan” appears in internal agendas. The closure is being planned two years before the public will be told.

The Birney household financial picture shifts: Keith Birney leaves Facebook (listed as employer in 2020 F1) and by 2024 lists no employer at all. The Medium network remains active. The @json.knight backlink farm goes live in December 2023, connecting to 46+ fake persona websites on purpose-built hosting infrastructure.

2024: The Double Play

Two property transfers are executed simultaneously:

1. Plymouth Housing receives $5.5M in free land at 16725 Cleveland Street via a 22-day sprint with zero public process. This serves dual purposes: it provides “affordable housing” political cover while conditioning the public to accept city property transfers without competitive bidding.

2. The OFH internal decision is made (July 31, 2024: “satellite site”). The Transfer Option Agreement with Plymouth is being amended through the summer, with the feasibility period extended — suggesting the deal is more complex than a simple gift.

The five-month black hole (September 2024 through January 2025) covers the period when both property transactions are being finalized, the PR firm is hired, and the closure machinery is assembled. Not one email from this period was produced in the PRA response.

2025: The Execution

The public announcement comes March 11, 2025 — less than three weeks before the facility closes on March 31. The manufactured talking points, embargoed press materials, and template citizen responses are ready because they’ve been in development since November 2024. The PR firm costs more per month ($4,468.75) than the building’s maintenance ($3,083).

When opposition emerges:
- Steve Fields (political opponent) — 114 emails withheld
- Sasha Glenn (community advocate) — physically surveilled, tracked by staff, threatened with permanent expulsion via weaponized Code of Conduct
- The Mayor — appears as a ghost in her own PRA production (8 emails, 229.8:1 mention-to-sent ratio)

The PRA response is a masterwork of technical suppression: 80% padding to create the illusion of compliance, 96% file corruption to destroy metadata, 4,109 attachments stripped (including contracts, financials, and legal documents), and every decision-maker’s outgoing emails purged.

The Council votes 5-1 on the Plymouth Omnibus Financing Resolution (no public comment). Then 6-0 to demolish the OFH — with no budget and no timeline for rebuilding. Steve Fields loses his seat in November 2025. The last opposition voice is gone.

The Endgame (Projected):

The OFH site — now cleared, transit-adjacent (light rail opened May 2025), and upzoned to 144 feet / FAR 8.0 — sits as a blank canvas. The “rebuild” has no budget and no timeline. NLG sits next door with 22 acres already under development. The mayor who facilitated the closure sits on the OneRedmond board with NLG principals. The campaign surplus sits in an account with minimal oversight.

At some point — after a decent interval, after public attention has moved on — the cleared lot will be declared surplus. The development agreement will be with NLG or an NLG affiliate. The 300-400 unit luxury tower will be presented as “transit-oriented development” and “downtown revitalization.” The community center that stood there for 73 years, built by 75 volunteers, will be a footnote.

Unless someone stops it.

## THE UNANSWERED QUESTIONS

These are the threads that could prove or disprove the full theory. Each represents a potential subpoena target, PRA request, or investigative lead.

### Critical (Could Prove the Core Theory)

1. Does NLG’s 22-acre assembly include or border the OFH parcel? King County GIS parcel data would show this. If NLG owns parcels contiguous to OFH on multiple sides, the land assembly theory is proven.

2. Has anyone filed development inquiries for the OFH parcel? Pre-application conference records at Development Services would reveal if developers have already approached the city about the site.

3. Were there executive sessions about OFH property disposition? Executive session agendas are public record even when minutes are not. If the Council discussed selling the OFH site in executive session, that’s dispositive.

4. What assets did the Redmond Public Corporation hold before Ord. 2979 dissolved it? If the OFH parcel was among those assets, the dissolution was the first step in freeing it for disposal.

5. What is “Redmond PSH” in the Omnibus Financing Resolution? Is this the Plymouth Housing project, or does “PSH” (Permanent Supportive Housing) encompass additional properties — possibly including the OFH site?

6. What contracts were awarded under the March 2020 emergency declaration? The emergency suspended normal procurement oversight. Were any contracts awarded to NLG, OneRedmond members, or Birney-connected entities during this period?

### Important (Could Expand the Theory)

7. Subpoena Medium for Keith Birney network account creation records, IPs, and private messages. If the 15 shell accounts were created from the same IP or device, the coordination is proven beyond inference.

8. Subpoena NameCheap for registrant identity behind the 46+ fake persona domains. The Withheld for Privacy ehf (Iceland) shield can be pierced by subpoena. This would identify who is paying for the backlink infrastructure.

9. Subpoena Vacares LLC for hosting account details. The Austin, TX address is a virtual office. The Cedar Park, TX address is residential. Who lives there?

10. What is Keith Birney’s current income source? The 2024 financial disclosure lists no employer. Is there an LLC registered in another state? Is there consulting income flowing through the shell network infrastructure?

11. Has the city awarded contracts to any entity at 11027 166th Pl NE (Birney residence)? Or to any entity associated with Keith Birney?

12. Do any council members who voted 6-0 to demolish have financial connections to NLG, Mill Creek, or Legacy Partners? Campaign finance records for all seven council members would reveal cross-pollination.

13. When did data.redmond.gov go dark? The city’s open data portal now redirects to a generic Socrata homepage. When was it taken down, and what datasets were on it?

### Speculative (Could Open New Fronts)

14. Is the Stepherson & Associates contract connected to OneRedmond or developer interests? Who referred S&A to the city? Do S&A principals have financial relationships with any Birney donors?

15. Are any of the Medium shell account identities aware their names are being used? Christopher Payne is now President/COO of DoorDash. Does he know there’s a Medium account in his name following the mayor’s husband? If not, that’s identity theft.

16. Are the 115 adult/escort domains on the Vacares LLC IP connected to any Redmond entities? Probably not — but the co-location of fake persona sites with adult content sites on purpose-built infrastructure is unusual enough to warrant investigation.

17. Has Plymouth Housing’s $321M in assets been audited for related-party transactions? Nonprofit finances are opaque. Are any Plymouth Housing board members connected to Redmond developers?

18. What happened to the 2,104+ petition signatures? Were they entered into the public record? Were they presented to Council? Or were they filed and forgotten?

## THE CAST OF CHARACTERS

### The Inner Circle

Name | Role | Evidence Level
--- | --- | ---
Angela Birney | Mayor. Decision-maker. Ghost in her own PRA production. | PROVEN (suppression, donor circuit)
Keith Birney | Spouse. Medium network hub. Patent holder in web indexing. Missing employer. | PROVEN (network) + SPECULATIVE (backlink farm)
Osman Salahuddin | Deputy Mayor. Zero outgoing emails produced. Called opponents “NIMBYs.” | PROVEN (ghost, Plymouth)
Malisa Files | COO. Coordinated Mayor’s talking points. 84 reply-to proofs, 6 produced. | PROVEN (suppression)

### The Operators

Name | Role | Evidence Level
--- | --- | ---
Derek Wing | Communications Director. Controlled OFH + Plymouth narrative. Channel-switched. | PROVEN
Loreen Hamilton | Parks Director. “Final decision-making authority.” Censored teen email. Forwarded surveillance. | PROVEN
Erica Chua | Highest-volume emailer (778). Filed surveillance report. Announced closure internally. | PROVEN
Carol Helland | Development Services Director. Presented Plymouth Transfer Option to Council. | PROVEN
Brant DeLarme | Talking points, embargoed materials, manufactured press. | PROVEN
Lisa Maher | “In a meeting with the Mayor and Loreen so these edits include their feedback.” | PROVEN

### The Beneficiaries

Name | Role | Evidence Level
--- | --- | ---
Nelson Legacy Group | 22 acres adjacent. $11K+ to Birney. 3 OneRedmond seats. 244+ units filed. | PROVEN (donor, proximity, board)
Plymouth Housing | $5.5M free land. OneRedmond member. $321M in assets. | PROVEN (recipient)
OneRedmond | Business coalition. Mayor + council on board with developers. $300K city contracts. | PROVEN (structure)

### The Silenced

Name | Role | Evidence Level
--- | --- | ---
Steve Fields | Political opponent. 114 emails withheld. Lost council seat 2025. | PROVEN (ghost)
Sasha Glenn | Community advocate. Physically surveilled. Threatened with expulsion. | PROVEN
Jonathan Choe | Journalist. Banned from council meetings. Broke Plymouth story. | PROVEN
Tommy Smith | Fire Chief. Fired + $95K NDA for COVID whistleblowing. | PROVEN
Linda Cole-Weaver | Citizen. Connected Plymouth to OFH in real time. Email duplicated 35x (padding). | PROVEN

## TIMELINE OF KEY DATES FOR LEGAL ACTION

Date | Event | Statute of Limitations Note
--- | --- | ---
Nov 2019 | Shell accounts created | Digital evidence — no SOL on fraud
Mar 2020 | Emergency procurement bypass | 3 years for fraud (expired), but ongoing scheme extends
Jul 2020 | $49,999.99 investigation + NDA | Pattern evidence for current claims
Jan 2023 | Internal closure planning begins | Within 3-year window for fraud
Apr 2024 | Plymouth Transfer Option signed | Within all SOL windows
Jul 2024 | Internal OFH closure decision | Within all SOL windows
Sep 2024-Jan 2025 | Five-month evidence gap | Active suppression — tolling argument
Mar 2025 | Public announcement + PRA suppression | Within all SOL windows
Apr 2025 | Omnibus Financing Resolution | Within all SOL windows
Nov 2025 | Demolition vote (6-0, no budget) | Within all SOL windows

Washington Public Records Act (RCW 42.56): Daily penalties of $100/day per record for agencies that fail to comply. No statute of limitations on PRA claims — the violation is ongoing as long as records are withheld.

Fraud/Corruption: RCW 9A.80 (official misconduct), RCW 42.20 (misuse of public office). 3-year SOL for most, but “continuing course of conduct” doctrine may extend for ongoing scheme.

## HOW TO USE THIS DOCUMENT

For a lawyer: Layers 1, 2, and 4 are the strongest. The land play, Plymouth maneuver, and PRA suppression are provable with existing evidence. Start with a PRA enforcement action (daily penalties, no SOL), use discovery to access the suppressed records, then build the corruption case from what’s found.

For a journalist: The flowchart and playbook comparison (Layer 6) are the narrative. Three times the same administration used the same pattern: decide in secret, control the message, silence dissent, destroy evidence, game thresholds. That’s a story.

For the public: The numbers speak. $11,000 in developer donations. $5.5 million in free public land. 911 withheld emails. 4,109 stripped attachments. A building that stood for 73 years, starved for six, and demolished with no plan to replace it. The lot sits empty next to the developer who paid for the mayor who closed it.

For the Council: The 6-0 demolition vote with no budget and no timeline is a blank check. Any future council can declare the cleared lot surplus. If you voted for demolition believing a rebuild would follow, ask yourself: where is the money? Where is the timeline? And who benefits when neither appears?

This document was compiled from forensic analysis of PRA Request #32782 (4 installments, 7,573 documents), Washington PDC campaign finance records, USPTO patent records, Medium.com network analysis, WHOIS/DNS infrastructure analysis, King County property records, OneRedmond corporate filings, and Plymouth Housing Group Form 990 data.

Every “PROVEN” designation is supported by primary source evidence. Every “INFERRED” designation meets preponderance standard. Every “SPECULATIVE” designation is clearly marked and logically derived from proven elements.

The standard throughout is not “beyond reasonable doubt.” It is “more likely than not.” And on that standard, the evidence is overwhelming.

“It was decided.”

Who decided? When? For whose benefit?

We know. They know we know. And now you know too.

← Back to Evidence Brief · ↑ Back to Top